A council three down

The resignation of Waipā councillor Elwyn Andree-Wiltens on Monday has left the council light on numbers as elected representatives debate several major issues.

Elwyn Andree-Wiltens

The council was three elected members down this week with Andree-Wiltens’ sudden departure following The News’ exclusive reporting of her financial interest in a sand quarry operating illegally on the banks of the Waikato River.

Hazel Barnes has leave of absence and Grahame Webber misses meetings as a result of ongoing cancer treatment.

Starting next week, the council will look to set its rates for the year and find money to pay for several projects not identified in its Long Term Plan such as a Sports Hall of Fame at the Velodrome.

Plus, councillors must address the pressing issue of the district’s transport requirements including the issue of a third bridge over the Waikato River in Cambridge. Then there are the Three Waters reform, staff shortages, rampant inflation and housing pressures to deal with.

Garry Dyet

“It’s a busy time,” chief executive Garry Dyet told the council on Tuesday, and he must now pull together a recommendation on how to cover Andree-Wiltens’ positions on the council, Cambridge Community Board, Maungatautari Reserve Committee, Heritage Fund and the Waikato-Tainui Joint Management Agreement.

Andree-Wiltens, the Maungatautari ward councillor for nearly six years and a community board member before that, released a statement on Tuesday apologising to the council for her involvement in the unauthorised quarry.

“It has always been my intention to engage with the community by being respectful and taking into account their concerns. I have always intended to provide an environment of integrity and trust to the community.  A space that people know they can come to voice their concern and know they will be listened to.”

The News reported last week Beacon Hill Contracting, the company behind the sand quarry, had applied for a retrospective resource consent to mine the operation. Elwyn Andree-Wiltens is an equal shareholder with husband Albert, son Mark and daughter-in-law Julia.

Waipa Mayor Jim Mylchreest

At the time mayor Jim Mylchreest refused to comment on whether he was considering suspending Andree-Wiltens or whether sand from the quarry was used in any district projects.

But on Friday, following pressure from deputy mayor Liz Stolwyk and other senior councillors, Mylchreest called for Andree-Wiltens’ resignation saying he was “really disappointed” in her and said he told her a higher standard was expected of elected politicians because of the perception of bias.

The resource consent application would not be fast tracked and would be processed by independent consultants and independent commissioners, all paid for by Beacon Hill Contracting, said Mylchreest.

All operations at the mine were suspended on April 13 after a Waipā enforcement officer visited the site to meet the Beacon Hill owners and their consultant.

Rhys Powell

By Sunday, Rhys Powell, the man who tipped off the Waikato Regional Council to the sand quarry’s existence, had lodged a Code of Conduct complaint with Waipā council saying he would take legal action if it did not act.

Dyet told Powell this week the council would “look into the wider issues relating to the matters” and would respond at the completion of the process.

Waikato Regional councillor Stu Kneebone said he knew little about the issue but had been assured by staff an investigation was ongoing into whether the quarry required a regional council consent to operate.

Read: Exclusive – Waipa councillor resigns

Read: Exclusive – Councillor told: resign

Read: Consent sought for controversial quarry

Read: Complaint made over quarry

We Say
The resignation of councillor Elwyn Andree-Wiltens appeared an inevitability, but it is also a loss to the Maungatautari community and is nothing to celebrate.

It was the consequence of a story broken exclusively by The News on April 1, and the fact we continued as the only media  prepared to follow up the issue and demand answers.

In short, it illustrates the value of a robust, privately owned community newspaper.

Despite our constant prompting, Waipā District Council took three weeks to illustrate it understood the seriousness of the issue, and the Waikato Regional Council also appears to have been slow on the pick up.

This is not the end of the matter. An audit must be carried out to determine where sand taken from the illegal quarry went.

More Recent News

Quarries – where they are in Waipā

Feedback from businesses on the proposed quarry just outside Cambridge’s eastern boundary has prompted the Cambridge Chamber of Commerce to open its one-minute survey to residents so the chamber can get a clearer community view…

A couple of servers

Waipā couple Ken and Karen Morris, pictured with the Governor-General Dame Cindy Kiro at Government House in Wellington last week when they received Queen Service Medals (QSM) for their services to the community. The Cambridge…

New church berm blessed

A new memorial berm at St Stephen’s Church, Tamahere, is a nod to the past as well as the future. The church, built in 1970 following a night of arson which saw three churches attacked…

New code for councillors

A new Code of Conduct to keep tabs on elected members’ behaviour has been adopted by Waipā District Council. The biggest change from the previous one adopted in November 2020 is an independent process to…